LexonTech

Tech, mostly Apple, from Lex Friedman.

SponsorHello Weather: The friendly, no-nonsense weather app for iOS and Android.Try it free

As Overcast experiments with ad skipping, I worry about the future of podcasting

Just as Google’s AI results are ruining the web by capturing traffic that would otherwise go to websites that depend on those views, podcast ad-skipping is going to be very bad for podcasting.

As users, we’ll benefit from both in the short term: Google’s AI results, when accurate, are incredibly helpful. Skipping podcast ads makes the listening experience more pleasant. But when creators of websites and podcasts can’t make money, they’re far less incentivized to keep making great stuff.

As seen on Reddit and in Podnews, Marco Arment is beta testing an ad-skipping feature for Overcast, his popular podcast app. Currently, the feature is limited to Premium subscribers. You know, the ones with discretionary income who are most likely to spend money on the products and services advertised in podcasts.

Let me be frank: I use an ad blocker in my web browser. I used to love TiVo’s one-button ad skipping, which TiVo more recently turned into an add-on subscription service.

Marco describes ad-skipping as “table stakes” for podcast apps. I don’t quite think that’s true. Apple’s own Podcasts app remains one of the most popular podcast apps in the world, and it doesn’t offer a dedicated ad-skipping button. Spotify, meanwhile, is testing its own “Skip Ahead” feature for Premium subscribers.

As Marco has pointed out, podcast apps already have 30-second skip buttons. Listeners know that when certain ad breaks come up, they can tap that button two or four or six times and skip past big chunks of ads. But it requires some tapping back and forth and some finesse. You have to keep checking in to see where you are, and you might catch a few blips of the ads you’re trying to skip. It’s better than nothing.

The feature being tested in Overcast lets listeners skip nearly an entire ad break with a tap. Importantly, it doesn’t skip ads automatically; the listener has to choose to do it. Marco says it stops a few seconds before the ad ends, which may be where the call to action is. That’s better than nothing, too.

In some ways, the industry brought this problem on itself.

I spent a decade and a half leading teams that sold podcast ads, and I took ad load very seriously. That’s the number of ads and the duration of ads that could run in a given show. If a show were 45 minutes or longer, I felt like it could support up to two pre-rolls and up to four mid-rolls, with the latter divided into two breaks. That’s roughly five minutes of ads out of a 45-minute show, a significantly lower ad load than TV or radio.

But some shows now pack in a much higher ad load, including shows I love. SmartLess often opens with two to three minutes of back-to-back ads, spots I’d consider mid-roll length in the pre-roll position. I listen to a couple iHeart shows with more ad breaks than other shows, and more ads within those breaks, too. Some episodes of the excellent Heavyweight are more than 25 percent ads.

And of course, there’s been a steady march toward more programmatic and pre-produced ads in podcasts, rather than the host-read ads that resonated better with listeners, alienated them less, and performed better for advertisers.

Packing in more and more ads has the short-term benefit — for podcasters and ad sellers — of generating more revenue. But it also absolutely trains us as listeners to skip the ads.

Again, I made my career in podcast monetization, and I know exactly how many times to press the 30-second skip button on certain shows with abhorrent ad loads. I do so with only minimal guilt.

To be clear, I don’t think Marco is doing something wrong by experimenting with this feature for Overcast. I recently wrote about my intrigue with Ben Rice McCarthy’s new app, Tripod, which extracts promo codes from show notes when they’re available so you can easily find the deals advertised on your favorite shows. That’s clever.

But if ad-skipping becomes more prevalent for podcasts, it’s going to mean fewer podcasts can make money. And if fewer podcasts and their hosts can make money, we’re going to get fewer great shows from independent creators.